I spent a while on TradersList as someone hunting for a decent volume indicator. It is a curated directory of trading indicators and platforms, sorted by where you use them (TradingView, MetaTrader, ThinkOrSwim) and by what they do (volume, price action, statistics). The curation angle is the pitch and that part mostly holds up. One thing to know upfront: there is no account. "Join" is not a signup, it just drops you into a Telegram channel, and bookmarks live only in your browser. So there is nothing to log into, which is fine, but the UI keeps implying otherwise. The listing pages are the real value. Each one has an editor summary, a plain explanation of how the indicator works, how to set your range, a short Q&A and a sentiment line. A few of them explained the tool better than its own source page. "Get This" sends you straight to the real download. What I liked: - Instant search and filters that actually work, across a few hundred well-sorted listings - Detail pages go well past a link dump, with genuinely useful how-it-works and how-to-use writeups - "Get This" links straight to the original source (mql5, TradingView), nothing locked behind a wall - No signup, no paywall, fast to load - Clean dark interface, readable on mobile What I didn't like: - "Join" looks like an account button but only opens Telegram, and there is no account system at all - Bookmarks are browser-only, and after I bookmarked an item the Bookmarks page still showed "0 items" and "Page 1 / 0" - The About page claims 400+ indicators, 200+ platforms and 100+ concepts, but the real counts are 333, 97 and zero (Concepts is "coming soon") - Concepts sits as a main nav tab on every page while being empty, and the footer "Concepts" link goes to the Terms of Service page - The header is inconsistent between pages, with bookmark and menu icons on some and not others - Reviews are labelled "TradersList Reviews" with no author and read like generated text, and the star widget under "Review Indicator" did nothing when clicked - Comments just means "Read on Telegram", and "Join Telegram" is pushed four or five times per page - Opening a listing from a direct link renders it as a popup over the list with a close X, which is disorienting - On desktop, About and some content sit in a narrow left column with half the screen empty - The homepage repeats itself, with CoinGlass and FlowAlgo showing up in two different platform rows The idea is useful and the listing pages are solid reference material. But the inflated stats, the empty Concepts tab, the shaky bookmarks and the Telegram-only "membership" make it feel more like a content project than a product right now. Around 3 out of 5. Good for a quick research pass, not something I would trust as a saved workspace.