Usability68Design71Speed88Security74Accessibility79Growth63

Cycling through all six. Tap any point to stop.

Measured on six things

YouTube comment exporter to CSV, Excel and JSON, with AI reports

Growth

63

Real, specific problem with a clear wedge: five platforms, no login, pay-per-row, AI grouping into buying signals. Early (domain registered 2026-11-13) but the positioning is sharper than ExportComments' subscription model.

Screenshots

1 / 1

About this app

AI Comment Exporter reads the public comments of a YouTube video, TikTok video, Instagram post, X post or Reddit thread from a pasted link. The comment count and first 500 comments are free to read, search and filter down to questions. One click exports every comment, with replies if you want them, to an Excel-ready CSV or JSON file. The AI report reads the top comments and groups them into questions, complaints, buying signals and requests, each listed with the original comments. It also includes free random comment pickers for giveaways. No API key, extension or login to YouTube is needed, and you pay only for the rows you export.

Key features

  • 1Free read of the first 500 comments from any public YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, X or Reddit post — no login, API key or extension.
  • 2One-click export of every comment and reply to Excel-ready CSV or JSON, up to 1M rows, with likes, dates and reply chains.
  • 3AI report groups up to 5,000 comments into questions, complaints, buying signals, requests and praise, each with source comments.
  • 4Pay-per-row pricing: 300 points ($3) per 1,000 comments, 1,000 points ($10) per AI report; points never expire and failed work refunds.
  • 5Free random comment picker for giveaways with a public result page, seed and list fingerprint to prove fairness.
  • 6Email alerts for new comments on a post, daily or weekly, optionally filtered to chosen words.

Target customer profile

Drawn from the product itself, not from a survey.

Demographic

Content creators and YouTubers (10k–1M subscribers)

Pain points

Manually scrolling through thousands of comments to find questions, video ideas, or giveaway winners feels endless

Primary needs

Quickly export comments to spreadsheets, identify top questions, and fairly pick random winners for giveaways

Demographic

Social media managers and digital marketers

Pain points

Struggling to track audience sentiment, complaints, and buying intent across multiple platforms in one place

Primary needs

AI-powered reports that surface complaints and buying signals, plus bulk exporting across five platforms for analysis

Demographic

Market researchers and data analysts

Pain points

Existing tools are platform-specific, require logins, or lack structured data with reply threads and metadata

Primary needs

Clean, structured exports (CSV/JSON) with likes, dates, and reply chains, plus API/LLM integration for deeper analysis

Scout Review

Written by AI from measured evidence, scored out of 100.

AI Comment Exporter is a focused, well-built tool for a real problem: pulling comments off YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, X and Reddit without a login, API key or extension, then either exporting them to CSV/JSON or letting an AI group them into questions, complaints, buying signals and requests. The free tier (first 500 comments, searchable and filterable) is a genuinely good hook, and the pay-per-row model ($3 per 1,000 comments, $10 AI report, points never expire) is fairer than the subscription alternatives for occasional users. The site is fast, the security headers are complete, and the guides hub shows real product thinking. The weak spots are presentation and trust: pricing is buried, the free-tools grid bloats the page, and there's no published security or accessibility statement. For a tool this young, that's a fixable list.

Measure by measure

Usability

68

Paste-a-link is the obvious first action, format tabs preview outputs in place, and the guides hub is unusually deep for a new tool. Pricing is buried in small text under the hero and one card near the bottom.

Design

71

Coherent brand: heavy grotesque headline with peach marker accent, mono eyebrow labels, and a real-data spreadsheet mockup that makes the output legible. Undercut by a ~20-card free-tools grid and low-contrast small text.

Speed

88

Lighthouse 100/100 on both mobile and desktop: LCP 908ms, CLS 0, TBT 90ms. The site also claims a 16-second run for 1,915 comments, timestamped on the live site.

Security

74

Full header stack verified: HSTS, CSP, frame protection, Referrer-Policy, Permissions-Policy, plus SPF and DMARC — 12/12 on the probe. No SOC 2, ISO or pen-test claims published, which is normal at this stage.

Accessibility

79

Lighthouse accessibility 100/100 with zero failing axe audits. No published WCAG statement and the site is English-only, which caps it below the top of the band despite a clean automated run.

Growth

63

Real, specific problem with a clear wedge: five platforms, no login, pay-per-row, AI grouping into buying signals. Early (domain registered 2026-11-13) but the positioning is sharper than ExportComments' subscription model.

Improvement areas

  • Pricing is buried in small text under the hero and one card near the bottom — move it above the fold.
  • The ~20-card free-tools grid reads as SEO padding and pushes pricing and FAQ far down the page.
  • No published security page, SOC 2, ISO or pen-test summary despite handling comment data and exports.
  • No accessibility statement and no manual keyboard/screen-reader verification beyond the automated axe run.

Design & Usability

The homepage does the hard thing well: it shows the product instead of describing it. A spreadsheet mockup with real handles, timestamps and a '1,915 rows · 15 columns' footer lands the value in about four seconds, and the paste-a-link field sits right under the headline so the first action is obvious. Format tabs (Spreadsheet, AI report, Giveaway) let you preview each output without leaving the page. The guides hub is deeper than most tools twice this age — separate walkthroughs for giveaways, competitor research, and per-platform workflows. Where it slips: a ~20-card free-tools grid reads as SEO padding and pushes pricing and FAQ far down, and the actual cost ($3 per 1,000 comments, $10 AI report) hides in small grey text under the hero. Move pricing up, trim the card wall.

Speed & Security

Speed is the standout. Lighthouse returns 100/100 on both mobile and desktop with LCP 908ms, CLS 0 and TBT 90ms — the kind of numbers most SaaS sites don't hit on a good day. The site also publishes a timestamped 16-second run for 1,915 comments, which is the right way to make a performance claim. Security is solid on the technical side: HTTPS enforced, HSTS, CSP, frame protection, Referrer-Policy, Permissions-Policy, SPF and DMARC all verified — 12/12 on the header probe. What's missing is the trust layer: no SOC 2, no ISO, no pen-test summary, no security page. For a tool that ingests public comments and stores exports, a short 'how we handle your data' page would close the gap cheaply.

Accessibility & Growth

Accessibility scores 100/100 on the Lighthouse axe run with no failing audits — a clean automated baseline. The caveats are the usual ones: automated checks cover roughly a third of WCAG, there's no published accessibility statement, and the site is English-only. Keyboard and screen-reader behavior on the interactive bits (the paste field, format tabs, FAQ accordion) is worth a manual pass. Growth is the interesting question. The problem is real and specific — creators and social managers genuinely drown in comments — and the wedge is sharper than the alternatives: five platforms in one place, no login, pay-per-row instead of a subscription, and an AI report that groups comments into questions, complaints, buying signals and requests with the source comments attached. ExportComments charges a subscription and skips the AI; the open-source downloader is YouTube-only and CLI. The limits: the category is crowded, per-row pricing is a harder sell than flat subscriptions for heavy users, and the domain was registered in November 2026, so there's no traction evidence yet. The idea can grow; execution and distribution will decide how far.

Conclusion

If you're a creator or social manager who actually reads comments for a living, this is worth a test run — paste a link, see the first 500 free, and decide whether the AI report earns its $10. The product is competent and the pricing is honest. What it needs next is trust scaffolding: a security page, an accessibility statement, and pricing moved above the fold. None of that is hard, and all of it would move this from 'promising indie tool' to 'the obvious pick'.

Suggestions for improvement

  • Move the $3 per 1,000 comments / $10 AI report pricing above the fold instead of burying it in small text under the hero.
  • Collapse the ~20-card free-tools grid into a compact linked index so pricing and FAQ aren't pushed down the page.
  • Publish a short security page: how comment data is stored, retention, and whether any third-party audit exists.
  • Add an accessibility statement and a manual keyboard/screen-reader pass on the paste field, format tabs and FAQ accordion.
How we score

Alternatives comparison

Named competitors, point by point. Nobody paid to appear here or to be left out.

AI Comment ExporterExportCommentsYouTube Comment Downloader (open-source)
Platforms supportedYouTube, TikTok, Instagram, X, RedditMultiple platforms (YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, X, etc.)YouTube only
AI analysis of commentsYes — groups into questions, complaints, buying signals, requests, praiseNo AI groupingNo
Pricing modelPay-per-row: $3 per 1,000 comments, $10 AI report; points never expireSubscription required for full exportsFree, open source
Login / API key requiredNo login, API key or extension neededAccount requiredNo login; CLI install required
Free tierFirst 500 comments free, searchable and filterableLimited free preview; full export requires subscriptionFully free
Giveaway / random winner pickerYes — free picker with public result page, seed and fingerprintNo dedicated giveaway toolNo
Export formatsCSV, Excel-ready, JSON, Markdown AI reportExcel, CSVCSV, JSON

Comparing options? See AI Comment Exporter alternatives, scored side by side

View all Social Media
Scout Forge

A platform dedicated to providing unbiased reviews of newly launched applications, analyzing everything from their features to their full potential.

info@scoutforge.net

© 2026 Scoutforge. All rights reserved.